What is Closed-Loop Marketing?

Closed loop marketing is one of the key approaches that helps companies improve their performance. 

This is an approach that unites different departments of the company into a single chain. Marketers receive clear data on what actions lead to closing deals, which allows them to quickly adapt their strategy. For this system to work effectively, both departments need a common goal, such as gross profit or ROI.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

In this article, we'll take a look at what closed-loop marketing is, what its benefits are, and how to implement it in practice to achieve the best results.

What is Closed-Loop Marketing?

Closed-Loop Marketing is a strategy based on the connection and analysis of all marketing and sales data. It allows you to understand which actions bring the most benefit and which ones should be optimized or changed. 

‍

‍

Closed-Loop Marketing helps to track the customer journey from the first contact to the end of the sale, providing feedback between marketing and sales.

Closed-Loop Marketing helps companies track the success of each campaign and build long-term relationships with customers. The secret is in proper data collection and analysis.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

Benefits of Closed-Loop Marketing

Transparency of data and processes. Allows you to clearly track which marketing actions produce results and which do not.

Improved ROI. With the ability to analyze the effectiveness of campaigns, you can reduce the cost of ineffective tools and focus on the most profitable strategies.

‍Personalization of communications. Closed loop marketing allows you to create individualized offers based on audience behavior and interests.

Collaboration between departments. Ensures alignment between marketing and sales departments through unified access to data and analytics.

Essential Tools for Closed-Loop Marketing 

Without integrated tools, it's impossible to get a holistic picture of data. CRM and analytics help to collect information and ensure timely decision-making.
‍



Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

So, to successfully implement closed loop marketing, companies need effective tools that allow them to collect and analyze data.

1. CRM systems (Pipedrive, Salesforce).

These platforms allow you to track interactions with customers at all stages: from the first contact to the conclusion of a transaction.

2. Marketing analytics platforms (Google Analytics, Claspo).

They help analyze user behavior on the website and evaluate the effectiveness of various campaigns.

3. Automated marketing tools (MailChimp).

They allow you to launch automated campaigns and track their results in real time.

Customer Segmentation in Closed-Loop Marketing

Customer segmentation is a key element in the Closed-Loop Marketing strategy. Proper segmentation allows you to customize marketing actions to the specific needs of different customer groups.

We divide customers into five categories: “refrigerator” (cold customers), ‘warm’ (microwave), ‘studying’ (no one has bought yet, but they have more chances than ‘warm’), ‘active’ (buying and returning), and ‘regular’ (buying once a month). Each segment requires its own set of marketing tools and approaches. Sales managers and marketers work with each segment to achieve a common goal.
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

‍

Segmentation allows you to:

Personalize communications: send relevant offers to each customer group.

Optimize resources: focus efforts on segments with the highest conversion potential.

Increase loyalty: provide a better experience for regular customers.

Four Key Stages of Implementing Closed-Loop Marketing

Bogdan Zyuzenko, Customer Success Manager at Promodo, offers four critical stages that form the basis for the effective implementation of Closed-Loop Marketing.

Customer Acquisition and Identification

At the initial stage, it is important not only to attract the attention of potential customers through various marketing channels - SEO, contextual advertising, social media, etc. - but also to identify them. Identification involves collecting key information about the customer and their behavior for further analysis and segmentation. 

Identification is segmentation using CRM. We attract customers and correctly classify them in our system, which allows us to work with them effectively in the future.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

Segmentation of the Customer Base

The second step is to segment your customers based on the data you've collected. This is critical for understanding the diversity of needs and behavioral patterns of your audience. We suggest dividing customers into five main categories:

• “Cold“ customers (”fridge") - people who have not yet shown an active interest in a product or service.
• “Warm“ customers (”microwave") - potential customers with initial interest who need an additional incentive.
• Customers in the pipeline are those with whom we are actively working, and the likelihood of conversion is much higher.

• “Active customers are those who have already made a purchase and have a positive experience of interaction.
• “Regular” customers are regular customers with high loyalty who make purchases on a regular basis, for example, monthly.

In-depth Analysis of Each Segment

The third stage involves a detailed analysis of each segment to identify the specific needs, motivations, and barriers for each customer group. This includes:

Quantitative analysis - determining the volume of customers in each segment.

Qualitative analysis - studying behavioral characteristics, preferences and expectations.

Feedback - direct communication with customers, especially those who did not complete the purchase, to understand the reasons and analyze improvements.

Conduct in-depth analysis of the number of customers in each segment and study their behavior. Initiate direct contact with customers to get feedback, ask them how you can improve your service, why they didn't complete the purchase, or what factors are holding them back from cooperation.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

Tailoring Marketing Strategies to Each Segment

‍

Based on the insights gained in the previous stages, the fourth stage involves adapting marketing tools and approaches for each individual segment. This includes developing personalized strategies that best meet the needs and expectations of different customer groups:

• For “cold” customers, educational and informative materials to raise awareness and stimulate interest.

• For warm customers - more detailed offers, special promotions or demos to encourage further interaction.

• For “pending” customers - individual consultations, resolving objections, providing social proof (testimonials, case studies).

• For “active” customers - loyalty programs, recommendations of additional products or services, cross-selling.
• For “regular” customers, we offer exclusive offers, VIP service, and a personal manager to increase their loyalty and value to the business.

Adapting marketing tools to each customer segment allows you to maximize the use of resources and increase conversion in each group. This is a strategic approach that ensures a high level of personalization and relevance of marketing efforts.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

The effectiveness of Closed-Loop Marketing directly depends on the thoroughness and consistency of each of these stages. 

How to Apply Closed-Loop Marketing

Implementation of Closed loop marketing requires successive steps:

1. Defining key performance indicators (KPIs). First, it's important to establish which metrics to use to evaluate the success of campaigns.
2. Integration of tools and data collection. It is necessary to ensure that all data sources are combined - from the website to CRM.
3. Data analysis and optimization. After the campaigns are launched, we analyze the actions that gave the best results.
4. Implementation of changes based on the data obtained. Based on the analysis, we adjust current strategies to achieve maximum results.

Implementation of Closed-Loop Marketing in a Distribution company: A Case Study

Context

A distribution company that imported and sold its own brands of travel products in various price segments - from economy to premium - in Ukraine, including

- flashlights costing $100 and more

- knives and tents;

- other travel products.

The company had a comprehensive sales structure:

B2B segment: an extensive distribution and dealer network.

B2C segment: own retail mono-branded stores and an active travel community.

Issues

The traditional model of the company's work involved the separate functioning of marketing and sales departments. The marketing department generated leads, which it passed on to the sales department without further joint analysis or coordination. This led to a number of problems:

1. Lack of synergy between marketing and sales departments.

2. Low conversion rate due to lack of awareness of marketing initiatives by sales managers.

3. Suboptimal use of resources and communication tools.

Strategic solution: Implementation of Closed-Loop Marketing

The goal was to integrate the marketing and sales departments, creating a single ecosystem where these units work in concert at all stages of the sales funnel. The key components of the strategy included:

Setting Unified Business Goals and KPIs

• Common goal: to achieve specific gross profit, ROI and sales targets for key brands. 

• Agreed KPIs for both departments, which stimulate cooperation and information exchange.

Implementing a Modern CRM system

Centralization of customer data, which ensures transparency and accessibility of information for all stakeholders.

Automation of segmentation processes, interaction tracking, and performance analysis.

Customer Base Segmentation by Behavioral and Demographic Traits

• “Cold customers: minimal interaction, low readiness to buy.
• “Warm customers: show initial interest, need additional information.
• Customers “in processing”: high conversion potential, active interaction.
• “Active” customers: have made a purchase and demonstrated a positive experience of interaction.
• “Regular customers: high loyalty, regular purchases.

Integrated Collaboration Between Marketing and Sales Departments

• Joint planning and implementation of marketing campaigns.
• Exchange of analytical data and feedback for continuous improvement of strategies.
• Increasing the competence of sales managers through the provision of marketing materials and training.

Practical Implementation and Tools

Utilizing Content Marketing and Video Materials

• Video crash tests of expensive flashlights as an effective sales tool that demonstrates the reliability and quality of products.
• Personalized email campaigns tailored to the specifics of each segment.

Campaign Analysis and Optimization

• Monitoring the effectiveness of various lead generation channels: contextual advertising, SEO, email marketing, cold calling.
• Adjusting the strategy based on the data to maximize ROI.

Sales Manager Training and Support Conclusion

• Providing sales scripts, arguments, and materials for working with different segments.
• Regular meetings and trainings to share experience and improve the efficiency of communication with customers.

Results

- Increase conversion through more accurate targeting and personalization of offers.

- Optimize your marketing budget by focusing resources on the most effective channels and segments.

- Improved interaction between marketing and sales departments, which led to increased team motivation and productivity.

- Increased customer loyalty through more relevant and valuable communications.

Recommendations

• Synergy between marketing and sales departments is a critical success factor in today's business environment. Closed-Loop Marketing ensures this synergy by integrating processes and goals.

‍

• Using a CRM system allows you to automate processes and gain in-depth insights into customer behavior.

‍

• Segmentation and personalization are key elements that ensure high efficiency of marketing campaigns and increase customer satisfaction.

‍

The implementation of Closed-Loop Marketing has changed our company. By combining the efforts of marketing and sales, we were able not only to achieve our goals, but also to build sustainable relationships with customers. This is an approach that I recommend to all companies that want to realize their full potential in the market.
‍
Bogdan Zuzenko
Customer Success Manager

Conclusion

Implementation of Closed-Loop Marketing requires investments in technologies such as CRM systems and analytical platforms, as well as changes in the company's internal processes. However, the long-term benefits of this approach far outweigh the initial costs, ensuring sustainable business growth and development.

The practical application of Closed-Loop Marketing allows you to:

1. Increase the ROI of marketing campaigns through resource optimization and targeted actions.

2. Improve customer experience through relevant and valuable offers.

3. Strengthen cooperation between marketing and sales departments by creating a single information ecosystem.

4. Increase the company's competitiveness in the market through an in-depth understanding of customer needs and rapid adaptation to changes.

‍